Â
In the quiet suburb of Amityville, New York, lies a house that has become synonymous with horror and intrigue. The story of 112 Ocean Avenue, known globally as The Amityville Horror, is a chilling tapestry woven from tragedy, alleged paranormal activity, and a long-standing debate about the legitimacy of these hauntings. This article delves into the grim history, the numerous films inspired by the events, and the ongoing debate on whether it was all an elaborate hoax.
The Infamous House on Ocean Avenue
The story of the Amityville Horror began on November 13, 1974, when Ronald DeFeo Jr. walked into his family’s home and shot and killed six members of his family while they slept. DeFeo claimed that he was driven to commit the murders by voices in his head and that he believed his family was plotting against him. He was convicted of second-degree murder and is currently serving six concurrent life sentences in prison.
Following the tragedy, the house on Ocean Avenue sat empty for over a year until it was purchased by George and Kathy Lutz in December 1975. The couple moved into the house with Kathy’s three children from a previous marriage, but they only lasted 28 days before fleeing in terror and claiming the house was haunted by evil spirits.
The Hauntings
In the short time that the Lutz family lived in the house, they reported experiencing a series of supernatural phenomena. These included strange odors, slamming doors, green slime oozing from walls, and unexplainable cold spots. George also claimed to have woken up at 3:15am every night, which was the time of the DeFeo murders. The Lutz family also reported seeing red eyes staring at them from outside their windows and being physically touched by unseen hands.
The couple eventually contacted renowned paranormal investigators Ed and Lorraine Warren, who spent a night in the house and claimed to experience similar phenomena. The Warrens declared the house to be “inhabited by demonic forces” and that it needed to be exorcised.
The Controversy
The story of the Amityville Horror spread like wildfire, and soon, the town was overrun with tourists and curious onlookers. However, not everyone believed the Lutz family’s claims. Critics argued that the couple’s financial troubles and the sensationalized media coverage of the DeFeo murders had influenced their story.
In fact, several key details in the Lutz family’s account were found to be inconsistent or exaggerated. For example, the green slime was never seen by anyone else, and the red eyes outside the window turned out to be a neighbor’s outdoor light. The Warrens were also criticized for using the Amityville Horror to further their own careers.
The Legacy
Despite the controversy, the Amityville Horror has become a cultural phenomenon. The story has been adapted into numerous books, movies, and TV shows, each with their own interpretation of events. Many still flock to the town of Amityville to see the infamous house for themselves.
The Murders that Started It All
The saga began on a dark night in 1974. Ronald DeFeo Jr., the eldest son of the DeFeo family, committed a heinous act by brutally murdering his parents and four siblings as they slept. The grisly massacre shocked the Amityville community and etched the house at 112 Ocean Avenue into the annals of crime history. The motive behind Ronald’s actions remains murky, adding another layer of mystery to the already dark narrative.
The Lutz Family’s Terrifying Experience
Just over a year after the DeFeo murders, the Lutz family—George, Kathy, and their three children—moved into the ill-fated house. What was meant to be a dream home soon turned into a 28-day nightmare. According to their accounts, they experienced an array of paranormal phenomena: strange odours, inexplicable cold spots, and disturbing apparitions. The Lutz family fled the house in January 1976, leaving behind most of their belongings, convinced that malevolent forces had driven them out.
Jay Anson’s “The Amityville Horror”
In 1977, Jay Anson published “The Amityville Horror,” a book chronicling the Lutz family’s harrowing experiences. The book was an instant bestseller, captivating readers with its portrayal of the supernatural events allegedly plaguing the house. It laid the groundwork for the 1979 film adaptation and several other movies that followed, each adding its own embellishments to the story.
Cinematic Universe
The fascination with The Amityville Horror has spawned numerous films, each exploring different facets of the legend – to various degrees of success…
The Amityville Horror (1979)
Directed by Stuart Rosenberg, this classic horror film closely follows the Lutz family’s terrifying ordeal. It became a seminal piece in the horror genre, significantly contributing to the popularization of the Amityville haunting. The movie stars James Brolin and Margot Kidder as George and Kathy Lutz, with Rod Steiger as Father Delaney, the priest who attempts to rid the house of its evil presence.
Amityville II: The Possession (1982)
This prequel delves into the DeFeo family’s tragic history, focusing on the events leading up to the murders. It explores the dark influences that may have driven Ronald DeFeo Jr. to commit such a gruesome act. Directed by Damiano Damiani, the film stars James Olson and Burt Young as Father Adamsky, a priest who becomes involved in the case.
Amityville 3-D (1983)
Presented in 3D, this instalment follows a sceptical reporter investigating the Lutz case, only to be confronted by the house’s supernatural forces. The film marks a shift towards more traditional horror elements.
The Amityville Horror (2005)
A modern remake directed by Andrew Douglas, starring Ryan Reynolds and Melissa George, this film revisits the original storyline with updated special effects and a more intense focus on the house’s malevolence.
The Amityville Haunting (2011)
Using a found-footage format, this film presents a fictionalised account of a new family experiencing similar horrors in the Amityville house, capitalising on the contemporary trend of found-footage horror.
The Amityville Asylum (2013)
A British horror film taking a unique approach, it centres on a young woman working at the infamous house, now an asylum, who encounters paranormal activity.
Amityville: The Awakening (2017)
Directed by Franck Khalfoun, this instalment follows a single mother and her children who move into the Amityville house, unaware of its dark history. It adopts a more psychological horror theme.
These films, along with various documentaries and TV adaptations, have fuelled the ongoing debate about the reality of the Amityville haunting.
The Debate: Haunting or Hoax?
The story of The Amityville Horror has always been divisive, with passionate arguments on both sides.
Believers in the Haunting
- Consistent Accounts: Proponents argue that the detailed and consistent accounts of the Lutz family and various witnesses lend credibility to the haunting.
- Physical Evidence: Supporters point to physical evidence, including photos and audio recordings of unexplained phenomena.
- Spiritual Attachment: Some believe that spirits can attach to people rather than places, explaining why subsequent owners did not report similar experiences.
Skeptics of the Haunting
- Inconsistencies: Critics highlight inconsistencies in the Lutz family’s timeline and lack of corroboration from independent sources.
- Debunked Evidence: Investigations have debunked some of the physical evidence, such as the infamous “hoof prints” in the snow.
- Financial Motive: The sceptical camp suggests that the Lutz family’s financial gain from book and movie deals indicates a possible motive for fabricating their story.
- Lack of Independent Verification: The absence of verifiable evidence beyond the Lutz family’s accounts diminishes the credibility of the haunting claims.
Credible Sources and Personal Accounts
To provide a balanced perspective, it is essential to reference credible sources and personal accounts from those directly involved.
- Lorraine Warren, a renowned paranormal investigator, shared her insights in a 1980s TV interview, emphasising the malevolent presence she and her husband Ed encountered at the Amityville house.
- George Lutz gave an interview in the early 2000s, discussing his experiences and his thoughts on the ongoing debate.
- Neighbours and Community Members: Contemporary interviews with neighbours who recall the atmosphere during the Lutz family’s brief stay add depth to the narrative.
- Paranormal Investigators: Recent written accounts by investigators who visited the house offer fresh perspectives on the purported hauntings.
Conclusion: The Amityville Enigma
The Amityville Horror remains an enigmatic blend of true crime, alleged supernatural activity, and pop culture phenomenon. Whether one believes in the paranormal or views the story as an elaborate hoax, there is no denying its impact on horror literature and cinema.
As we reflect on the tale of 112 Ocean Avenue, we find ourselves at the crossroads of scepticism and belief, where personal growth and shared experiences through thoughtful reflection foster a deeper understanding of the mysteries that continue to captivate our imagination. The Amityville Horror is not just a story of ghosts and ghouls but a testament to the power of storytelling and the enduring quest for truth in the face of uncertainty.