In Defence of “Lady in the Water”. Why it is One of My Top 5 Films of All Time

Navigating the diverse and often tumultuous world of cinema, M. Night Shyamalan’s “Lady in the Water” stands out as an extraordinary creation that continues to resonate deeply within me. It’s not just a good film in my eyes—it’s one of my all-time favourites, a significant entry in my personal top five list. This piece is dedicated to exploring why “Lady in the Water” holds such a revered spot in my cinematic heart, despite its critical panning and box office struggles.

My Personal Connection with Shyamalan’s Work

To understand why “Lady in the Water” has captivated me so profoundly, it’s important to acknowledge my broader appreciation for Shyamalan’s oeuvre. Unlike many who laud “The Sixth Sense” as his magnum opus, I’ve always found myself drawn to his more polarizing works. Shyamalan’s willingness to take risks, to delve into the mystical and the metaphorical, has always appealed to me.

“Lady in the Water” represents a career low for Shyamalan in terms of critical reception. However, to me, it showcased his unique storytelling prowess at its finest. The film’s narrative, intertwined with fairytale elements, struck a chord deep within me. Its ability to blend real-life tragedy with fantasy is something I find both haunting and hopeful, akin to Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” where the resolution to characters’ conflicts is found in the realm of fantasy, providing a distant but necessary hope.

The Power of Paul Giamatti’s Performance

Paul Giamatti’s portrayal of Cleveland Heep, a lonely, bereaved man, is nothing short of remarkable. Giamatti’s performance is central to the film’s emotional impact. His depiction of a man lost in grief and despair, only to find a spark of hope through an extraordinary circumstance, resonated with me on a deeply personal level.

One scene that stands out is Heep’s heart-wrenching breakdown as he recounts the tragic loss of his family. Giamatti’s raw emotion in this moment is palpable, making it impossible not to empathize with his character’s pain. This scene sets the foundation for Heep’s eventual transformation, where he emerges as a figure of purpose and strength within his fractured community. This journey from despair to hope is a powerful narrative that stays with you long after the credits roll.

Bryce Dallas Howard’s Enigmatic ‘Story’

Bryce Dallas Howard’s character, Story, serves as the literal and metaphorical ‘fish out of water.’ Her ethereal presence and the mystery surrounding her origins bring a sense of wonder and intrigue to the film. Howard’s performance is subtle yet impactful, embodying a character that is both otherworldly and deeply human.

Story’s journey of self-discovery, where she ultimately embraces her destiny, is a poignant narrative thread. Her interactions with Cleveland Heep, particularly their discussions about purpose and storytelling, are moments that emphasize the transformative power of narratives. These dialogues resonate deeply with me, highlighting the pursuit of meaning in life and the impact of stories in shaping our realities.

Shyamalan’s Masterful Use of Cinematography and Symbolism

One of Shyamalan’s greatest strengths as a filmmaker lies in his meticulous attention to detail, particularly in his use of cinematography and symbolism. “Lady in the Water” is a visual feast, with carefully crafted shots and a deliberate use of colour that enhances the narrative. The film’s visual storytelling invites viewers to engage actively, to look for clues and references that add depth to the viewing experience.

This collaborative relationship between the film and its audience is something I deeply appreciate. Unlike filmmakers who rigidly control their narratives, Shyamalan leaves space for viewers to interpret and take ownership of the story. This openness allows for a personal connection with the film, where each viewing can reveal new insights and meanings.

Thematic Resonance and Emotional Impact

At its core, “Lady in the Water” is a film about hope, purpose, and the power of community. It’s a modern fairy tale that speaks to both children and adults, combining fantastical elements with real-life struggles. The film’s exploration of these themes is what makes it stand out to me as a top film.

Cleveland Heep’s transformation from a man consumed by grief to a figure of resilience and purpose is a compelling narrative arc. This journey is not just about individual redemption but also about the collective strength of a community coming together. The final scene, where each character finds their place in the story, conveys a powerful message of unity and shared destiny. It underscores the importance of community and the idea that ordinary individuals have the potential to become extraordinary.

Comparing “Lady in the Water” to My Other Top Films

“Lady in the Water” occupies an interesting position in my top five films, which is otherwise dominated by horror classics:

1. Dawn of the Dead (1978)
2. The Exorcist
3. Hereditary
4. The Exorcist III
5. Lady in the Water

While the other films in my list delve into the darker aspects of the human psyche and the supernatural, “Lady in the Water” offers a different kind of emotional resonance. It broke through my horror-centric preferences and managed to stay with me because of its unique blend of fantasy and reality. The film’s emphasis on hope and the transformative power of narratives provides a refreshing contrast to the more harrowing themes of the other films in my list.

Specific Scenes and Dialogues That Resonated With Me

Several scenes and dialogues in “Lady in the Water” have left a lasting impression on me. Here are a few that stand out:

Cleveland Heep’s Emotional Breakdown

This scene, where Heep shares the tragic story of his family’s murder, is incredibly powerful. Giamatti’s performance is raw and authentic, capturing the depths of human despair. This moment sets the stage for Heep’s eventual healing and transformation, highlighting the resilience of the human spirit.

Conversations Between Story and Cleveland Heep

The dialogues between Story and Cleveland Heep, where they discuss the importance of finding one’s purpose, are profoundly moving. These conversations underscore the film’s central themes of self-discovery and the impact of storytelling on our lives. They remind us of the power of narratives to shape our identities and destinies.

Story’s Embrace of Her Destiny

The moment when Story discovers her role and purpose in the world is a pivotal scene. It symbolizes self-discovery and the fulfilment of one’s potential, which is a universal theme that resonates with viewers. This scene is a testament to the film’s message of hope and transformation.

The Final Scene of Unity

The final scene, where the characters come together and each finds their place in the story, is a beautiful depiction of community and shared narratives. It conveys a sense of hope and unity, emphasizing the importance of collective strength and support. This scene is a powerful reminder of the impact we can have on each other’s lives.

Supporting Arguments for “Lady in the Water” as a Top Film

Despite its initial poor reception, “Lady in the Water” has garnered a growing appreciation over the years. Here are some additional arguments to support my claim that it is one of the top films:

1. Critical Insights: Some critics and scholars have revisited the film and recognized its depth, allegorical storytelling, and unique approach to the fairy tale genre. They highlight its emotional and philosophical undertones, which may have been overlooked during its initial release.
2. Audience Reception: The film has developed a cult following, with a growing audience that appreciates its emotional and narrative depth. Online forums and fan theories reflect a community of viewers who find value in its storytelling and themes.
3. Cinematic Analysis: “Lady in the Water” is rich in visual storytelling, with meticulously crafted shots, use of colour, and symbolism that enhance the narrative. These elements invite repeated viewings and deeper engagement with the film.
4. Character Development: The transformation of characters, particularly Cleveland Heep, from despair to purpose, is a compelling and relatable journey. This character arc adds to the film’s emotional impact and resonates with viewers.
5. Thematic Resonance: The film’s exploration of hope, purpose, and the power of storytelling offers timeless and universal messages. These themes, combined with the film’s narrative structure, create a profound and meaningful viewing experience.

Conclusion: The Enduring Appeal of “Lady in the Water”

“Lady in the Water” remains a cherished film for me, not just for its narrative and cinematic qualities, but for the deep emotional resonance it evokes. Its exploration of hope, purpose, and community, combined with outstanding performances and Shyamalan’s masterful storytelling, make it a standout film in my eyes.

While it may not have received the acclaim it deserves, “Lady in the Water” has found a special place in the hearts of those who appreciate its unique blend of fantasy and reality. For me, it will always be one of my top five films—a testament to the power of storytelling and the resilience of the human spirit.

As we navigate our own journeys, films like “Lady in the Water” remind us of the importance of finding our purpose, embracing our potential, and supporting each other in our shared narratives. It is these messages that make the film truly unforgettable and deserving of its place among the greatest cinematic works of all time.

If you liked this, you may also like my feature on The Happening